The Truth About TikTok Shop: Is It Worth Your Time?

‍

#TikTokMadeMeBuyIt has 14.5M posts as of Feb 2024.

This statistic is proof that TikTok has grown into a legitimate shopping destination.

Millions of users watch videos of people sharing their purchases, creating a massive community around finding and buying products on the platform. This organic behavior grew so big that TikTok couldn't ignore it.

They thought, Why make users hop through multiple platforms when they can discover and buy in the same scroll?

Hence, launched — TikTok Shop.

While the platform shows promising signs for brands seeking new revenue streams, jumping in headfirst requires careful consideration.

What is TikTok Shop?

TikTok Shop is an in-app commerce feature that lets users purchase products directly while watching TikTok videos, without leaving the platform. Unlike traditional social commerce where links direct users to external websites, TikTok Shop creates a seamless shopping experience within the app itself.

The platform operates through two main channels:

• Direct selling by brands
• Affiliate marketing

TikTok creators can tag products in their content and earn affiliate commissions from sales they generate. This creates a network of micro-salespeople who authentically showcase products to their engaged audiences.

Brands need to upload their product catalog, set commission rates, and approve creators who want to promote their items. When a viewer taps on a tagged product in a creator's video or LIVE stream, they can complete their purchase without interrupting their browsing experience.

Why TikTok Shop is Capturing Everyone's Attention

TikTok Shop's launch couldn't be better timed. DTC brands are facing a perfect storm in their traditional marketing channels.

The Rising Costs, and Hurdles of Customer Acquisition

Meta's ad costs have skyrocketed, with some brands reporting 25-40% increase in customer acquisition costs. iOS privacy changes have made tracking customer journeys feel like solving a puzzle blindfolded. The old playbook of scaling through Facebook and Instagram ads simply isn't delivering the same returns.

Push From TikTok

TikTok is also aggressively pushing the feature.

The platform is offering significant incentives: subsidized shipping, reduced commission fees, and prominent placement in the app. They're essentially paying brands and creators to make this work. They're boosting shop-related content in the algorithm. It's essentially a starter package for rapid growth.

The Appeal of A Proven Model

Meanwhile, TikTok Shop arrives with proof of concept already established. In Southeast Asia, social commerce is mainstream—platforms like Douyin (TikTok's Chinese counterpart) drove approximately $274.2 billion) in e-commerce sales within the first ten months of 2023. For many brands, this Asian success story feels like a preview of what's possible in Western markets.

Source

👉 This creates an interesting dynamic. Marketing teams are looking at TikTok Shop through two lenses: the immediate opportunity (lower acquisition costs, ready-to-buy audience) and the FOMO factor (getting in early while TikTok is actively supporting growth).

TikTok is an Impulse Purchase Paradise

TikTok's genius lies in removing friction between product discovery and purchase.

When users see a $20 aesthetic water bottle or a viral beauty hack, they can buy instantly—no time to second-guess, no switching apps, no lost momentum. This immediate gratification loop works especially well for visually appealing, trend-driven products. It's why beauty brands, desk accessories, and fashion items often see explosive success: they perfectly match TikTok's "see it, want it, buy it" ecosystem.

The early wins on TikTok Shop are undeniably attractive—instant sales spikes, viral moments, and acquisition costs that make Meta look expensive. But seasoned marketers are asking more critical questions:

What happens when these training wheels come off? Are these viral spikes building sustainable customer relationships, or are we trading long-term brand equity for short-term sales? Are these quick wins setting up your brand for long-term success, or are they just a sugar rush that leaves you dependent on the platform's whims?

The real challenge isn't just capturing impulse purchases—it's building a customer base that returns even when your products aren't trending on their FYP.

Problems with TikTok Shop

TikTok Shop promises quick sales and viral moments, but it's not the marketing paradise it appears to be. While the platform offers tempting incentives and lower acquisition costs right now, relying too heavily on it could leave your brand vulnerable.

1. Limited Creator Pool

Finding the right creators for your brand on TikTok Shop isn't as free and open as it should be. You can only work with creators who've joined TikTok's affiliate program, which really shrinks your options.

This means you might end up working with creators who say yes to promoting any product just to make money, rather than those who truly love and understand your brand. It's like being forced to pick from a small group of salespeople instead of choosing someone who naturally fits your brand's style.

2. Saturated Creator Feeds

When you scroll through many TikTok Shop creators' profiles, it feels like watching a never-ending TV shopping channel. These creators post so many product promotions that their feeds become overwhelming.

Your product risks becoming just another item lost in this sea of "buy this, buy that" videos. This makes it hard for your brand to stand out or create any real connection with viewers who are getting tired of seeing sale after sale.

Sacha Gorelik, an e-commerce copywriter and brand strategist who's helped dozens of DTC brands craft their influencer programs, shares her perspective:

"You're always competing - competing for people's attention. And at some point if people feel like they're always being sold to they will stop viewing your content. The key is balance! Mix product highlights with behind-the-scenes content, customer stories, or fun trends to keep the profile engaging. Think of the content as a blend of education, conversation, entertainment, and sales.”

3. Creator Outreach is Difficult

Trying to connect with creators on TikTok Shop is like throwing darts in the dark. When brands reach out to creators, only about 1-2 people respond out of every 100 messages sent.

This means you either spend countless hours manually emailing creators or pay extra money for special tools to help you reach them. Either way, it's a headache that takes up too much time and resources.

4. Complex And Expensive Fee Structure

TikTok Shop's fee structure is complex and costly.

With the standard 6% fee, for a business doing $50,000 in monthly sales, that's $3,000 in fees alone.

Add in other costs like shipping, returns (which can be high in social commerce), customer service, and platform discounts/promotions, and you could easily be spending 15-20% of your revenue just on operational costs.

These layered costs can significantly impact profit margins and operational flexibility.

5. Unreliable Product Approval Process

Getting and keeping your products on TikTok Shop feels like walking on eggshells. The rules aren't always clear, and even tiny things can get your product rejected - maybe it's a specific word in your description, a certain ingredient, or just the way your product photo looks. What's allowed today might not be okay tomorrow.

For example, a skincare brand might get approved, then suddenly face issues because they used the word "treatment" instead of "cream." This constant uncertainty makes it hard for brands to plan their inventory and marketing strategies, as they never know when they might need to change their listings or face sudden removals.

6. The Platform Dependency Risk

The platform's volatility adds another layer of risk.

Building your influence strategy on rented land—especially one as unpredictable as TikTok—leaves your brand vulnerable to algorithmic changes, platform policies, or even complete shutdowns. Smart brands are realizing that true influence isn't platform-dependent; it's about building and owning authentic relationships with creators and their communities that transcend any single channel.

And the biggest problem of all is that…

TikTok Shop's Sales-First Approach Undermines Brand-Building

TikTok Shop pushes brands into a numbers game - it's all about how many sales you can get right now, how many clicks, and how many quick purchases. This might work if you're selling $10 impulse items that people buy without thinking too much.

But if you're trying to build a brand that lasts, or selling products that people need to trust before buying, this approach can actually hurt you in the long run.

Sacha Gorelik points out why authenticity matters more than sales tactics:

"One of the biggest mistakes is overly producing content. People gravitate towards videos that feel organic and natural, not overly scripted or polished. When working with creators, it's important to give clear creative direction but avoid boxing them into the same formula everyone else is using - cue the classic 'female influencer voice with upward intonation at the end of every sentence.' Let creators bring their unique personality to the content. Authenticity wins every time."

Even though TikTok encourages you to collaborate with creators, it's not in an organic way. TikTok Shop's approach to creator collaborations feels more like hiring sales representatives than building authentic partnerships.

Traditional influencer marketing works because it allows creators to weave products naturally into their content, building genuine advocacy over time. When viewers see their favorite creators consistently using and loving a product — without the pressure to sell — it creates authentic desire and trust.

TikTok Shop's structure sacrifices this long-term brand building for quick conversion wins, potentially damaging your brand's perception among both creators and consumers.

When your acquisition strategy revolves around impulse purchases, you attract price-sensitive customers who are less likely to become brand advocates. These buyers, drawn in by trending moments rather than genuine brand connections, often have lower lifetime value and higher return rates. They're shopping for deals, not investing in your brand story.

How Can You Build a Brand and Influence that Outlasts Any Platform?

While TikTok Shop's challenges might feel overwhelming, they point to an important lesson: successful brands need to think beyond any single platform.

The solution is not to find the perfect channel but to find ways you can build influence that lasts.

Adopt a Platform-Agnostic Approach

Instead of putting all your eggs in one basket (like TikTok Shop), focus on building relationships with creators who can represent your brand across different platforms.

Find people who truly get what your brand is about, not just someone who'll post about you for quick cash. Look for creators who naturally use and love products similar to yours, and whose style matches your brand's personality.

You can find any creator on the planet, in just a few minutes, on SARAL — an all-in-one influencer marketing platform.

Work with creators who have a strong presence across different platforms. When choosing partners, look for those who know how to adapt their style - maybe they're great at quick TikTok reviews but can also create detailed YouTube tutorials. This gives you flexibility and protects you from being dependent on any single platform's success.

Build An Influencer Community

Think of your creator relationships as building friendships rather than just business deals. When you genuinely connect with creators who love your brand, they'll stick with you regardless of where social media goes next.

Sacha Gorelik shares a powerful perspective on creating lasting partnerships:

"One-off deals are cool, but what if your creators became characters in your brand's story? Think about how people fall in love with characters from shows like The Office or How I Met Your Mother — you keep coming back because you're invested in them. It's the same with creators. Instead of quick collabs, build long-term partnerships with people who genuinely vibe with your brand. Engage with their content, get to know their style, and create ideas that feel real to their audience. Don't treat them like ad space — treat them like creative partners."

The key is treating creators like valued partners rather than just paid advertisers. Start by connecting with them personally — understand their content style, what they care about, and how they prefer to work with brands.

Create special programs like early product access, exclusive events, or creative workshops that make them feel part of your brand's journey. Learn how brands like Obvi, or Pura Vida keep in touch with influencers.

Set up simple systems to stay in touch regularly, maybe through monthly check-ins or a private Discord community. This way, creators become genuine fans who naturally want to share your products with their followers.

This way, when the next big social platform launches (and it will), you won't be starting from zero. You'll have a network of creators who already know, trust, and love your brand, ready to share your story wherever their audience goes next.

Look at Sustainable Growth Metrics

Don't get caught up in just watching sales numbers spike after each creator post. Pay attention to how people are talking about your brand in comments and shares.

Are they excited? Are they coming back to buy more?

Keep track of which creators bring in customers who stick around and buy again. This helps you spot the partnerships that are really working, not just causing temporary sales bumps. Look at metrics like repeat purchases and customer feedback to understand if you're building real brand loyalty.

Final Thoughts

While everyone around you might be rushing to figure out TikTok Shop (and whatever new platform launches tomorrow), we encourage you to stay focused on long-term success.

This is exactly why we built SARAL — to help brands manage their influencer relationships without getting caught up in the chaos of changing platforms. Whether your creators are on TikTok today, YouTube tomorrow, or whatever comes next, SARAL helps you keep those relationships strong and organized.

You shouldn't have to rebuild your influencer strategy every time a new shopping feature launches. Your creator relationships should be platform-proof, and that's what we help you achieve.

Book a quick demo with us, and we'll show you how SARAL can help you build sustainable influencer communities.

‍